J Scott Skinner

[emdee]

Just to try to stir up the forum a bit. What sort of profile does the music of James Scott Skinner have in Antrim (and Ireland generally)? I ask as a Skinner enthusiast for almost 40 years, and consider that Skinner was a huge influence and inspiration to me.

There is a lifetime's study in the music of Skinner alone, if one wants to get into the mind of this very intruiging individual, and I have been inspired and intrigued by him for the last 40 years.

I obviously know that he was not Irish, and that sometimes Michael Coleman is put forward as his Irish equivalent, but I just wonder if Skinner's personality and genius (Talent does what it can, Genius does what it must) had the strength to cross these divides and have influences beyond his native Kincardineshire. (Note not Aberdeenshire)

[Ptarmigan]

I think Ireland's answer to Skinner is more likely to be the late Sean McGuire
{December 26, 1927 - March 24, 2005}

In terms of training, ambitions, and outlook, McGuire is certainly comparable to a major figure in Scottish fiddling history named James Scott Skinner (1843-1927).

Sean McGuire

Cheers
Dick

[emdee]

It certainly would appear to be so. There are quite a few parallels between Sean McGuire and Skinners respective backgrounds and careers, although they were from different eras. I think Coleman being closer in time to Skinner, although a bit later, draws one towards a comparison.

As you will be aware, the Scottish fiddle player of the 20th Century who is now "revered" was the late Hector MacAndrew. I find his playing very traditional and north-east (obviously), and overflowing with character, but he did not bring any innovation to the music in the way McGuire did in Ireland. I have met people who worship MacAndrew, and others who do not like his style. Probably the same is true of Sean McGuire with "traditionalists".

So far as Skinner's recordings are concerned we have to remember that they were made when he was past his best, and there is also the factor that he is reputed to have a substantial alcohol habit. Whether that is true or not I don't know, if it is, he managed to survive into his 80s in spite of it.